PartyPlate

Catering marketplace vs ordering direct: an honest comparison

Both ways of booking a caterer work. Here’s when each one wins — including the fee, stated plainly.

We run a catering marketplace, so take this page for what it is: our own honest account of the trade-off. Ordering direct from a Halifax caterer is a perfectly good way to book food, and for some orders it’s the better way. A marketplace earns its keep on a different set of orders. Here’s how to tell which situation you’re in.

The fee, up front

PartyPlate charges customers a 5% service fee on the food subtotal, capped at $150. It’s shown before you confirm — never added as a surprise at the end. On a $400 food order that’s $20; on a $3,000 order the fee stops at $150 no matter how large the order gets.

One thing that does not change between the two routes: caterers set their own prices either way. The menu prices are the caterer’s prices. The marketplace fee is the cost of the services below — if those services aren’t worth 5% (capped) for your order, ordering direct is the right call, and we’d rather you know that than find out later.

When ordering direct is better

When a marketplace is better

The quick test: routine order, known caterer, small group, or custom menu → order direct. New event, comparing options, mixed dietary needs, or you want the cancellation guarantee → use the marketplace.

Side by side

Ordering directPartyPlate
Menu pricesSet by the catererSet by the caterer (same prices)
Extra costNone5% of food subtotal, capped at $150, shown up front
Comparing caterersOne phone call at a timeOne request, side-by-side menus
If the caterer cancelsYou negotiate the refund100% back
Minimum orderVaries by caterer$150 per caterer, 10+ guests
Off-menu custom workBest routeLimited to listed menus
ReceiptsKept by each catererAll in one account

Delivery, for reference, is set by each caterer either way — most charge $25–$35, and pickup is free. Nova Scotia’s 14% HST applies to catering orders the same way regardless of how you book.

There’s no wrong answer here — there’s only the answer that fits your order. If you’re planning something in HRM and want to see the marketplace side of the comparison for yourself, start here:

See what Halifax caterers offer

PartyPlate is launching January 2027 in HRM — compare local caterers, per-person menus, and dietary options in one place.

Compare Halifax caterers